He argues that a higher discount rate will make future damages look small, thus have less effort to reduce emissions today. The formula is used to explain why the social rate of return ought to be lower than the private rate and why this gapcalled environmental drag when measured in terms of equivalent evaporation of national. Because small changes in the discount rate have large impacts. For low and lowermiddleincome countries, a discount rate of at least 5% is more appropriate, and one around 4% for uppermiddleincome countries. The disagreements about the discount rate are not merely arguments about empirical matters. For example, the australian government recommends a social discount rate of 7 per cent with sensitivity analysis at 3 per cent and 11 per cent for policy appraisal, while the garnaut report applies social discount rates of 1. Choice of discount rate time horizon years discount rate % 25 50 100 200 0. On the one hand, it is the interest rate at which an agent discounts future events in preferences in a multiperiod model, which can be contrasted with the phrase discount factor. I also consider the issues that arise in choosing a discount rate to apply to very longrun projects and indicate how such rates should be chosen.
The university of texas at austin, 2003 supervisor. This paper is part of the environmental economics working paper series. You may need a pdf reader to view some of the files on this page. Arrow, social choice and individual values, 3rd ed. A discount rate, for those not in the know, is the flip side of an interest rate. Obviously, adopting a much higher discount rate as recommended by nordhaus around 5. Wilcoxen in chapter i, a two capital stock adjustment cost model is used to find the effects on productive capital investment of environmental regulation, which forces firms to invest in. This decomposition of social discount rates illustrates that, for example, the application of a 1. In many cases, the interest rate used in performing economic analysis is set equal to the minimum attractive rate of return marr of the decision maker. Discounting and relative prices in assessing future environmental. For instance, with a discount rate of five percent, a benefit or cost of onehundred dollars in ten years.
A summary report from two workshops on recent advances in social discounting practice and theory. Discount rates for environmental benefits occurring in the fardistant future. Yes, we should discount the fardistant future at its lowest possible rate. Social risk premium amount required to compensate capital owners for potential differences between expected and actual returns. The present value of net benefits pvnb is defined as. The discount rate is the interest rate charged to commercial banks and other depository institutions for loans received from the federal reserves discount window. Pure rate of time preference time discounting, also. In economics and finance, the term discount rate could mean one of two things, depending on context. Oct 18, 2019 the social discount rate generally applied in global health of 3% annually is inconsistent with rates of economic growth experienced outside the most advanced economies. I begin by locating the standard approach to discounting within the overall landscape of ethical theory. Economic theory predicts that, in a firstbest world, individuals will discount the future at the market rate of interest.
The economics climate change university of california. There are different theoretical arguments for using declining rates, and therefore recommendations on how fast the discount rate should decline also differ. Benefitcost analysis measuring benefits theory methods travel cost hedonic averting behavior contingent valuation measuring costs theory methods comparing benefits and costs decision rules discount rate sensitivity analysis an example. For instance, if somebody offers to pay to you eur 105 an year from now, the present value is eur 100 if you would earn interest of eur 5 on a deposit of eur 100. Evaluation of environmental investments procedures. In economic terms, this concern may be related to those services of the environment that are consumed directly rather than being employed in production, and to. Keywords environment, discount rate, utilitarian, welfare economics, climate change, biodiversity jel classi. Should governments use a declining discount rate in project. This article surveys the debate over the social discount rate. The dice model uses the estimated market return on capital as the discount rate, around an average of 4%.
The economics climate change department of agricultural. Proponents of the zero discount rate argue that discounting can almost entirely devalue the economic impact of even catastrophic environmental events occurring outside a 50year time horizon. Choices on discount rates have important implications for the outcomes of economic evaluations of health interventions and policies. Three essays on environmental economics publication no. Sec quantifying risk the 3 alternatives to costbenefit. Social risk free cost of capital the rate of return that is earned when there is absolutely no risk of earning more or less than the expected return. As a result, social planners using a high discount rate will have a tendency to favor projects with shortrun benefits. We will first shows how to apply the idea of present discounted value to a stock and then we will show how to apply it to a bond. Both the timing of impacts and the discount rate itself have an important effect on cba. Environmental impact analysis 106 economic impact analysis 107 regulatory impact analysis 107 costeffectiveness analysis 108 damage assessment 109 green gdp 110 benefitcost analysis 111 the basic framework 1 scope of the program 116 discounting 117 choice of discount rate 119 discounting and future generations 120. Environmental economics todays environmental experts have a wide range of tools at their disposal for the design and evaluation of local, state, regional, and national policies.
Mar 30, 2010 many environmental economists, including me, are troubled by the use of almost any discount rate greater than zero to calculate the current worth of values future benefits and harms that will occur more than a generation from now an issue of especially importance in climate economics. However, perhaps the most popular argument derives from the fact that future economic growth is uncertain for example, see weitzman, 2001 and gollier, 2002. The theory of benefitcost analysis dictates that the benefits and costs of a project that are certain should be converted to consumption units and discounted to the present using the consumption discount rate e. Natural environments and the social rate of discount. Discounting reflects how individuals value economic resources.
Ee981052 why the fardistant future should be discounted at its lowest possible rate. A formula is derived for the ratio of social to private discount rates as a simple function of two operational environmental parameters. The discount rate is used by economists to compare economic effects occurring at different times. Although there is some empirical evidence of hyperbolic discounting, others have found that exponential discounting is more accurate when behavioral factors are properly considered. With emergence of ecological economics as a separate branch of economics, the concept of ecological or in other words, environmental discount rate has been elaborated. A lower discount rate will make future damages look larger, thus put more effort to reduce emissions today. The decision rule comparing the internal rate of return and the discount rate can be restated equivalently as the. A discount is a deduction in percentage from the original price offered by the supplier. In this paper i show that environmentalism itself can provide a rigorous foundation for the low and declining discount rates that environmentalists seem to favor. February 3, 2009 as is often the case in economics, an obscure and often dullsounding issue, can quickly get into some deep moral questions.
The economics of climate change and the theory of discounting. Understanding individual discounting behavior of future costs and benefits is critical for designing environmental policy. Here are our previous efforts at explaining benefitcost analysis organized into a sort of a primitive, poorly written, illconceived, primer. A number of relatively recent textbooks in environmental. Secondly, they show that the discount rate is negatively related to a suite of behaviors that mitigate environmental health threats, from very lowcost steps like washing hands to more significant investments like household latrines, even after controlling for socioeconomic status, access to credit, public infrastructure and services, and. For example, stern 2008 and sterner and persson 2008 argue that the choice of consumption discount rate should be based almost entirely on ethical considerations. Robson, larry samuelson, in handbook of social economics, 2011. Lind, reassessing the governments discount rate policy in light of new theory and data in a world economy with a high degree of capital mobility, journal of environmental economics and management 18, no. Each of the methods described above uses a discount factor to translate values across time, so.
Discount rates of even 12 percent per year shift the costs of environmental degradation to later generations, and reduce incentives for longterm environmentally favourable projects. With a discount rate of 4%, one kilogram of rice delivered next year has a value of only 1. Intergenerational equity and the social discount rate. Environmental economics program at harvard university, and university fellow, resources for the future. The social discount rate is used to calculate the net present value npv of a time stream of benefits and costs of a project where its npv is calculated as. Assessing climate change impacts and mitigation policies involves a comparison of economic flows that occur in different points in time. Why the fardistant future should be discounted at its. Where an interest rate allows us to calculate how much something we have today like money in the bank will be worth in the future, a discount rate tells us how much something we will have in the future is worth to us today. Social discount rates sdrs are used to put a present value on costs and benefits that will occur at a later date. In the context of climate change policymaking, they are considered very important for working out how much todays society should invest in trying to limit the impacts of climate change in the future. On discount rates for economic evaluations in global health.
To define the social rate of discount hereafter, the discount rate, we adopt a wellestablished framework 12,14,16,32,36,37 and we assume that it is given by the rate. Towards an ecological communitarian normative foundation for ecological economics. The discount rate is the rate at which society as a whole is willing to trade off present for future benefits. Many environmental economists, including me, are troubled by the use of almost any discount rate greater than zero to calculate the current worth of values future benefits and harms that will occur more than a generation from now an issue of especially importance in climate economics. The views displayed in this document are those of the authors and do not reflect those of hm. Determinants of social discount rate, general case the economics of climate change c 175 the resulting equation r. National center for environmental economics 1200 pennsylvania avenue, nw mc 1809. The social rate of time preference and the social discount. Standard costbenefit analysis methods involve estimating the dollar values of costs. Gives the rate at which future value is discounted it holds. Many of these tools were developed at rff, and the organizations contribution to the field of environmental economics remains one of its greatest legacies. The decision rule comparing the internal rate of return and the discount rate can be restated. Economic tools have trouble pricing environmental goods, and the farther the cost element of costbenefit analysis is projected into the future, particularly through the analytical tool of the discount rate, the less reliable estimates are likely to be. This is realised through the mechanism known as discounting.
Gives the value of one unit in the future generally in one year in present value terms. The focus is on the economics rather than the philosophy literature, but the survey emphasizes foundations in ethical theory rather than highly technical details. This is the present or discounted value of one kilogram of wheat next year. On discount rates for economic evaluations in global. With a discount rate of 4 %, one kilogram of rice delivered next year has a value of only 1. From the environmental point of view, instead of exponential discounting when assessing future costs and benefits, a slowly declining rate of discount reaching zero percent per year could be used to. Pdf behavioural economics, hyperbolic discounting and. Framework for environmental economic decisionmaking 19 valuation of environmental costs and benefits 19 multiobjective decisionmaking or multicriteria analysis 28 the discount rate 33 risk and uncertainty 35 part ii. The discount rate in our analysis is tied closely to the population growth rate. Pdf the discount rate in environmental costbenefit analysis. Part 612 nrcs national resource economics handbook, water quality pdf, 4mb part 6 nrcs national resource economics handbook, developing cost data for conservation planning pdf, 261 kb. Ecological economics vol 69, issue 10, pages 18872044.
This concern has been heightened by the rise of the environmental movement and, particularly by the debate over sustainable development. Discount rates for environmental benefits occurring in the. Environmental economics discounting and time preference. The asset appropriate rate used in calculating the discounted cash flow value of a traded investment or corporate finance project. Further, there is little research on how environmental discount rates differ from. The discount rate applied in valuation models normally is the best rate of return that investors would earn alternative investments. The magnitude of these effects depends on properties of the economys. Dynamicmethods inenvironmentalandresource economics. In global health, such evaluations typically apply a discount rate of 3% for health outcomes and costs, mirroring guidance developed for highincome countries, notably the usa. Volumes i and ii of the handbook of energy and natural resource economics deal with the economics of renewable and environmental resources, including biological resources.
In the environment context, the economists notion of cost, or more precisely, opportunity. Environmental an introduction seventh edition barry c. Pvc present value of costs estimated as in equation 1, above. Environmental economics and sustainable development. For example, the present value of a catastrophic event occurring 50 years from today would be valued at less than 1 percent of its future value assuming. Price indexes and discount rates nrcs economics nrcs.
For instance, an evaluation of two view mammography for breast screening showed an undiscounted marginal cost per life year of. Many economists attempted to derive the correct discount rate for public sector projects. Use a discount rate of 4 % for the first 5 years, 3% for years 6 to year 25. Social discounting find the determinants of the discount rate from economic or ethical consid iiderations reasons to discount on preferenceutility side. The social rate of time preference and the social discount rate. The economics of the kyoto protocol pdf, world economics. Behavioural economics, hyperbolic discounting and environmental policy article pdf available in environmental and resource economics 462. Working paper series united states environmental protection. Cost effective analysis 1st equimarginal principle 2.
The discount rate is a rate used to convert future economic value into present economic value. Combining environmental and spatial discount rates for. The marr is also sometimes referred to as hurdle rate, required internal rate of return irr, return on investment roi, or discount rate. It should be noted that the net present value and net future value can be expressed relative to one another. Discount rates are used to compress a stream of future benefits and costs into a single present value. When weighing the decision to undertake a project with longterm benefits e. The table shows that this hesitation is not innocuous. Show full abstract economics suggest that general economic theory provides a clear and wellestablished benchmark as to what this discount rate should be. Choice of the discount rate the economics of climate change c 175 option 2. Volume iii focuses attention on depletable resources and energy resources. Environmental economics economics of environment positive economics what is was will be description normative economics what ought to be optimization environment treated as an asset. Oct 02, 1999 failure to discount future health related benefits will tend to show more favourable cost effectiveness ratios compared with discounting.
1308 22 998 1026 17 73 916 1112 1401 1078 1459 797 927 748 629 283 553 371 1444 12 217 764 1101 345 209 1179 1424 82 517 1043 273 250 670